Gotham’s New Power Player: Cristin Milioti Breaks Down Sofia Falcone’s Arkham-Fueled Descent in The Penguin

Gotham’s New Power Player: Cristin Milioti Breaks Down Sofia Falcone’s Arkham-Fueled Descent in The Penguin

Cristin Milioti is making waves as Sofia Falcone in HBO’s The Penguin, delivering a chilling performance that showcases her versatility. As the master of her craft, Milioti consistently stands out in every project she tackles, according to showrunner Lauren LeFranc. Now, she’s taking over Gotham in a way that has fans and critics buzzing.

Milioti’s entrance as Sofia Falcone is unforgettable: she glides through the Falcone mansion in a sleek cocktail dress and gas mask, surveying the bodies of her victims after gassing her family’s underworld dynasty in retaliation for years of betrayal. The scene evokes memories of Michelle Pfeiffer’s iconic turn as Selina Kyle in Batman Returns, a comparison that Milioti considers the highest of compliments.

“That performance is always with me,” Milioti admits. “I was seven when Batman Returns came out, and it terrified me, but I wanted to inject it straight into my veins.” Her childhood obsession with the Batman universe is no secret—she dressed as Pfeiffer’s Catwoman for Halloween, even convincing her parents to buy her a $20 costume with flimsy plastic nails. Milioti wore it constantly, embodying the character well beyond Halloween night.

Gotham’s New Power Player: Cristin Milioti Breaks Down Sofia Falcone’s Arkham-Fueled Descent in The Penguin

Milioti’s lifelong love of Batman surprised even The Penguin showrunner LeFranc. “She’s not just saying it. She genuinely means it,” LeFranc says of her star’s fan dedication.

Now, Milioti finds herself in a surreal full-circle moment, bringing a Bat-villain to life in the form of Sofia Falcone. Her portrayal of the ruthless heir to the Falcone empire, framed for murder and institutionalized at Arkham State Hospital, has become a standout performance in the series. In episode 4, Cent’anni, Sofia’s traumatic past is explored, revealing how her father, Carmine, framed her for his crimes and had her locked up. After enduring Arkham’s harsh conditions and electroshock treatments, Sofia emerges as a coiled viper, ready to strike at those who wronged her—most notably, Colin Farrell’s Oz Cobb (The Penguin), who is next on her list.

“I’ve been obsessed with this role since the moment I signed on,” Milioti says, describing the intense preparation she underwent to capture Sofia’s transformation from a poised mob daughter to a full-fledged villain. “You get to see her go from who she was to a full-blown villain in one hour. It’s like a movie.”

Milioti’s ability to balance Sofia’s unpredictability and menace is a testament to her skill as an actress. Known for her charm in romantic comedies, Milioti’s dramatic range often surprises audiences and collaborators alike. LeFranc praises her for transforming Sofia beyond anything she’d envisioned. “Once Cristin came in, I knew she was the perfect Sofia,” she says.

Farrell, who shares several intense scenes with Milioti, recalls their first scene together. “There was a lot of dancing around the elephants in the room. She was incredible,” he says of their onscreen chemistry.

The Penguin has been compared to The Sopranos for its gritty, mob-drama vibe, another moment of cosmic synchronicity for Milioti, who had a small role in the iconic HBO series as the daughter of mafioso Johnny Sack. Reflecting on that experience, Milioti admits she hadn’t watched the series at the time due to her family not having HBO, but the show became a profound moment in her early career.

Though Milioti has now become a seasoned actress with a wide range of roles under her belt, she recalls her early days auditioning for various projects, often struggling to find her place. A casting director’s advice to show her authentic self in auditions helped shape her career trajectory. “Auditions are brutal,” she says. “They never get easier.”

Gotham’s New Power Player: Cristin Milioti Breaks Down Sofia Falcone’s Arkham-Fueled Descent in The Penguin

Milioti’s journey through Hollywood has been about taking control of her career, carefully selecting roles that give her butterflies. Her standout performance in Black Mirror’s “U.S.S. Callister” cemented her ability to mix humor, darkness, and depth, and fans will be excited to hear that she’ll reprise the role in the upcoming Black Mirror season 7 sequel, arriving in 2025.

In The Penguin, Milioti finally steps into the comic book world after years of auditioning for various hero and villain roles. While she doesn’t name any specific projects, she’s glad those earlier opportunities didn’t work out. “I’m so glad I didn’t get any of those. I got to do it in a way that feels right for me.”

Fans of The Penguin would agree that Milioti’s Sofia Falcone is one of the most complex and unpredictable characters in the series, and her journey may not be over just yet. As the show sets the stage for The Batman Part II, fans are left hoping Milioti’s Sofia might make the leap to the big screen. “I would love to revisit her,” she says. “I mean, are you kidding?!”

For LeFranc, Milioti’s performance is nothing short of transformative. “She’s the best part of everything she’s in,” the showrunner declares. “She’s a chameleon.”

Latest new from Beuteeshop